Home / Church-State Issues / Houston Subpoenas High-Profile Pastors: Sermon Monitoring
Print Friendly and PDF

Houston Subpoenas High-Profile Pastors: Sermon Monitoring

Written by Robert Murphy on October 17, 2014

I saw several people denouncing this on social media, and I assumed they were exaggerating. But no, the city of Houston has been subpoenaing local pastors for written copies of their sermons. As the Houston Chronicle explains:

Houston’s embattled equal rights ordinance took another legal turn this week when it surfaced that city attorneys, in an unusual step, subpoenaed sermons given by local pastors who oppose the law and are tied to the conservative Christian activists that have sued the city.

Opponents of the equal rights ordinance are hoping to force a repeal referendum when they get their day in court in January, claiming City Attorney David Feldman wrongly determined they had not gathered enough valid signatures to qualify for the ballot. City attorneys issued subpoenas last month during the case’s discovery phase, seeking, among other communications, “all speeches, presentations, or sermons related to HERO, the Petition, Mayor Annise Parker, homosexuality, or gender identity prepared by, delivered by, revised by, or approved by you or in your possession.”

The subpoenas were issued to several high-profile pastors and religious leaders who have been vocal in opposing the ordinance. The Alliance Defending Freedom has filed a motion on behalf of the pastors seeking to quash the subpoenas.

The slippery-slope danger here is obvious: It’s very bad news if people worry that their public advocacy for an upcoming vote can invite government scrutiny.

However, beyond the obvious issues, let me raise the more general problem of taxation: The government can always justify its investigations into church sermons or the activities of many not-for-profit organizations because their special tax treatment comes with strings attached. Namely, they are not supposed to agitate for specific political candidates or other causes. Indeed, the cheekily titled “Freedom From Religion Foundation” organization won a lawsuit earlier this summer (filed in 2012) in which  the IRS agreed to step up its monitoring of churches in this respect.

(For the rest of my article, click the link.)

Continue Reading on consultingbyrpm.com

Print Friendly and PDF

Posting Policy:
We have no tolerance for comments containing violence, racism, vulgarity, profanity, all caps, or discourteous behavior. Thank you for partnering with us to maintain a courteous and useful public environment where we can engage in reasonable discourse. Read more.

5 thoughts on “Houston Subpoenas High-Profile Pastors: Sermon Monitoring

  1. This development gives me some hope. As anyone involved in the struggle over the sanctity of life and the sanctity of marriage knows, our pastors are key allies of the abortion and SSM forces in that they labor to divert the attention of their congregants away from this battle. There are plenty of Christians in this country to end abortion and same sex marriage tomorrow, but only a small number are politically engaged. This is because pastors labor to keep them focused on other things. For this reason our enemies have always exempted churches and pastors from the antichristian measures they impose on us such as the ACA abortion mandates. They go after cake bakers and photographers rather than pastors.

  2. But now they are going after pastors. Will this make them wake up to the danger? One can only hope.

  3. Phillip the Bruce says:

    Unable to connect to the link for the continuation. Is this a 'coincidence,' or something more sinister?

  4. My take on this is that the City of Houston jumped the gun. This is a little too much a little too soon. Better to just tighten the screws for a while, conditioning the public to accept more and more. This was definitely a tactical error on their part.

  5. Phillip the Bruce says:

    Guess it was a temporary glitch.